Narrator Voice: 9 ( with a 2 for the singing). OK I get it Cole is a singer, so is Sam, but lets just not have the characters sing, ok? It is bad.
Originality: 8. I Sorta saw some of this coming, but I was hooked anyways.
Absurdity: 5. This mostly has to do with the real life adult stuff that gets all glossed over. Does Sam do chores? Does he cook? Bank? Fine fine, we wont talk about it, but I know it is there. Also, Grace's parents are the worst and her Dad is the most absurd part of this book. Also, Sam's feelings: Absurdity = 8. Teenage boys just do not emote like this.
Level of Paranormal Romance: 9. Stay strong, teen-werewolf love.
Level of Harry-Potterness: 8. I find the way that Stiefvater turns a phrase grabs you and doesn't let go. Some if it just feels so REAL, their emotions and feelings towards eachother. It hooks you and you just cant stop.
Book Three is already on my phone to listen to....